Barfi! A Classic Tale Of Heart Vs. Mind

Well, I wasn’t blown away, but I was charmed.

I’m not one to get all gushy about filmy conceits like smiling your way through life’s tragedies or how to be happy even when the shit hits the fan, but what I can and always will appreciate is a love story well told. And that’s the part of Barfi that worked for me – the beautiful narrative of the relationships between Barfi, Jhilmil and Shruti.

Though the film is laced heavily – too heavily at times – with adoring tributes to the silent film era, Chaplin, Amelie and heavy doses (weirdly enough) of The Notebook, at its core it is a story about 3 people – two of whom are “chalta phirta dils” (“walking talking hearts”) portrayed by Ranbir Kapoor’s Murphy aka Barfi, and Priyanka Chopra’s Jhilmil.

And one is a woman who like most of us, succumbs to the practicalities of the mind – Ileana D’Cruz’s Shruti, forever torn between love and reason and in the bargain ending up in a sort of no man’s land where “you cry, but not all of your tears and laugh, but not all of your laughter” (to possibly mis-quote Kahlil Gibran).

This dichotomy is the backdrop of what might have been a mundane love triangle if not for Anurag Basu’s beautiful and lovingly etched characterization of the three, and the tender and tragic moments that transpire between them.

And so you have Barfi, Darjeeling’s resident deaf-mute charmer who falls for the graceful and pretty Shruti one fine day. Their relationship unfolds – and yes, I hate to say there is a lot of manic-pixie-dream-boying that ensues, but it didn’t bug me as much maybe because on Ranbir, the trope isn’t half bad. A lot also had to do with Basu’s restrained and subtle handling of each character relating to the other (a restraint he doesn’t show during too many goofy silent-era-throwback chase sequences between Ranbir and the endearingly hilarious Saurabh Shukla).

Things go awry between Shruti and Barfi and soon after, Barfi finds himself saddled with the autistic Jhilmil, a childhood friend with a tragic past of her own. Basu never really points up the handicaps or tragedies but treats them matter-of-factly. He certainly never uses the handicaps as plot devices which is refreshing for a Hindi film (after the Paas and Blacks). The turns of heart and plot in Barfi! run deeper and truer and therefore they are universal – this is one of the major triumphs of the movie.

Much has been written about the scene  between Barfi and Shruti after he visits her parents’ home and explains to her why he can’t be with her. It is undoubtedly one of the best scenes in the movie – Ranbir is brilliant in it – to convey so much without making a sound – only to be outdone by a scene just before the end,  where the love triangle between these three characters swells up to a heart-breakingly gorgeous crescendo. The impossible choice Shruti is faced with, the only right thing there is for her to do and the understanding with which the decision is made – it’s that scene that represents for me what Barfi! is all about.

All of that was gorgeously done. What doesn’t work is the back and forth narrative jumping between 1972 Darjeeling, 1978 Kolkata and present day. I felt this jumping around was completely unnecessary. Though the relationships are the heart of the story, the plot device Anurag uses to presumably keep the viewer engaged involves a rather convoluted kidnapping plot which ended up being neither here nor there. The suspense element worked in bits but I found myself, especially in the second half, wanting to see more of these characters interacting with each other rather than being stuck in the police station solving a rather uninteresting crime.

Performances! Ranbir will absolutely charm you and break your heart – he is effortless and his portrayal of Barfi is marked with abandon and yet a subtle restraint – it never gets so cutesy that it makes you want to (here it comes) barf. He knows when to hold back and just be a regular bloke – and he conveys everything from anger to sadness to boredom to love with the same “living-it” quality that he showcased in Rockstar. The dude is just awesome. Period.

And yes – PC was awesome too. I can’t say how accurate a portrayal it was of an autistic person as I’m not informed enough on that front but what I can say is that Jhilmil never once reminded me of the PC who invokes so much of my annoyance because of her off-screen antics. All I saw was Jhilmil and for an actor, there is probably no greater compliment than that. It takes major guts to go THIS de-glam – the role wasn’t just about un-prettying herself but really going all out embarrassing in a few scenes like the one where she’s singing at a party at her parents house, or the scene where she tells Barfi she has to use the toilet. Very few of today’s female stars would be willing to go there – so major props for that.

I also loved Ileana and oddly enough her Shruti was the character I related to the most. Without any gimmicky handicaps to hang her acting chops on, she still managed to shine with a lovely screen presence that is immediately likable. I felt ultimately the story really belonged to Shruti – and Shruti is us, neither handicapped nor disabled, and yet living with a severely compromised heart, perhaps the greatest disability of all. Ileana was the perfect narrator for the tale – conveying with ease every shade of pretty, graceful, torn, broken and ultimately free.

Like I said, I wasn’t blown away the way I was with Rockstar, for instance, and I did feel there were too many directorial tips of the hat to too many other films and filmic styles, but what won me over was the beautifully flawed, human love story between three unforgettable characters. I also suspect that it’s a film that lingers and grows on you with time. What it can’t be faulted for is the passion and earnestness with which it was made which is apparent in every gorgeously picturised frame.

Get Filmy Rating:





About these ads

16 comments on “Barfi! A Classic Tale Of Heart Vs. Mind

  1. I think I agree with your review the most .. my only gripe was the use of lot of directorial tricks/techniques/crutches to make certain impact .. but having said that Basu needs to be commended for his writing .. the chaplinesque stuff didn’t really work for me .. but he managed to comeback in the last 15 mins of the movie..I loved RK the most , PC was much much better than what she has ever done but she never “killed it” as I would like to describe it. Also, with Illeana , she surprised me the most … definitely one to watch out for in the future! All in all , a very good movie, could have been mindblowing but nonetheless a good effort!

    • mppj,

      Yeah I was a bit surprised by all the reviews praising Basu’s direction because i thought very little of it was original and he was just copying/borrowing various techniques from a lot of other films. But as you said, the *writing* was brilliant, especially the way he crafted the characters, and the last 15 minutes were just gorgeous.

  2. Yeaaaah………Say it again about Priyanka, go on, lol I’ll do my Rick James. Its not my kind of film but I will see it. eventually. things a pretty dire here in MI., for Bolly/Hindi films. plus Ranbir is growing on me. like a fungus.

  3. everyone is just going ga-ga over the film. Am just getting restless now and wanna watch it asap!
    Liked your post. it’s awesome! (as always :P)

  4. I absolutely loved the film. The nods to all those other films didn’t bother me, since they felt more like the heartfelt tribute of a film-lover than attempts at cinematic appropriation. Furthermore, Bengal just came alive in each of his assiduously crafted frames. The upor-neeche roads, the jatra masks, those sun-soaked fields, the phuchka (which I could just about taste) – I could just go on and on. One could just sense the love and care that had gone into each and every shot. I also loved how the story had so much potential for leaden melodrama and sappiness, but the film sidesteps those minefields with such joyous grace.
    With this, Ranbir’s become that actor whose films are going to be a must-watch simply because he’s in them. Rockstar is perhaps my favorite Hindi film in quite a while, and he’s sublime in Barfi!
    I’ve spoken often about how I can’t stand Priyanka’s public persona and several of her recent performances, but she is fantastic in this film – so brave, so quietly touching. Also, Ileana D’Cruz is a find. She totally won my heart.

    • Sal,

      Cinematography was brilliant, totally – and the attention to detail elevated it to a whole new level. Like mppj, the Chaplinesque stuff didn’t work for me but Basu hits the emotional notes bang on, so that made up for a lot of it.

      Also forgot to mention the sound design which was brilliant – between Pritam’s background score and the sudden moments of silence that gave us brief glimpses of what it was really like to be in Barfi’s world…nicely done.

  5. Love this Line: Shruti is us, neither handicapped nor disabled, and yet living with a severely compromised heart, perhaps the greatest disability of all.

    My wife came back raving about it to last night and mentioned Priyanka does a much better job than ShahRukh did playing someone autistic… Since she was the wild card for me, will maybe try to catch this in theaters. ( Since Heroine is still a no go for me however awesome Bebo looks)

    • Asim,

      I thought PC was good, I’d say her performance was more touching than SRK’s, it hit harder. There are bits and pieces here and there where it’s a *tad* overdone but it would just be bitchy of me to not give her her due. :) And yeah, Bebo’s hotness may drag me to theaters but I’ll wait to see the general gist of the reviews before I decide…

  6. I really want to see this film, my question though, could Katrina pulled off Illeana’s character? Anurag did go to Kat first, oddly enough.

    • Harpreet,

      OMG never!!! Kat would’ve ruined it! The character required a lot of quiet emotion, expressiveness of eyes, body language etc – IMO Kat would’ve just looked plastic throughout the whole thing and not sure how convincing she’d be as a Bangla bou. So thank GOD Kat didn’t do this film – would’ve been a disaster. Ileana was perfect.

  7. …..terrible movie. There is no reason for it to exist. Doesn’t make you feel anything at all for anyone.

  8. Love your blog (I’m a recent reader) but cannot agree with your Rockstar adoration. It was one of the worst and tritest films I’d ever seen. Disliked Ranbir (liked him in Wake up Sid), *hated* Nargis’s acting (or lack of it) and just overall spent time in the theater waiting for the movie to end (because stupid me can’t leave a movie before it finishes ;o))

    • Kaska,

      Nahiiiiiiiiin!!! :p Rockstar is my heart. Ranbir blew my mind in that. Yes, Nargis stuck out like a sore thumb and wish to God they had cast someone else but I loved loved the writing and I’m just an eternal sucker for a love story – the fact that it was a modern re-telling of Heer Ranjha and such an innovative one (IMO)….I just adore that movie.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 52 other followers

%d bloggers like this: